Johnny Pies Pizzeria

Next To Publix, 4855 Coconut Creek Pkwy, Coconut Creek, FL 33063, USA

About Johnny Pies Pizzeria

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Food Grub
    -
    January 16, 2026

    If your favorite part of a ceacer salad is croutons than you love this ceacer salad. I should have ordered a large very tasty dressing!! The pizza was good I had the grandma slice because my greys are coming in haha the sauce was very tasty! I got too full after the grandma slices, but I’m sure the meatball is also tasty

    Michelle Craig
    -
    June 07, 2026

    If you’re anywhere near Coconut Creek and craving great pizza, do yourself a favor and stop by Johnny’s Pies. This family-owned, mom-and-pop pizza shop has quickly become our new go-to spot whenever we’re in the area. What really stood out was the passion and pride behind every pizza. The manager has been making pizzas for over 40 years, works right behind the counter, and genuinely stands behind every pie that leaves the kitchen. That level of craftsmanship is hard to find these days. We ordered the Grandma Pie, and it was outstanding—perfectly crispy with incredible flavor and texture in every bite. You can tell they focus on doing the simple things exceptionally well. And don’t leave without trying the tiramisu. It was equally delicious and the perfect way to finish the meal. Great food, friendly service, and the kind of authentic neighborhood pizza shop that makes you want to come back again and again. Johnny’s Pies has officially earned a permanent spot on our Coconut Creek restaurant rotation.

    T T
    -
    June 05, 2026

    Considering the amount of reviews I've written, I guess cuz this is my regular weekly, sometimes twice a week, place. I can't believe I haven't written a review. Where do I start? The New York slice that if I close my eyes I'm back in the Bronx. The friendly employees that are like my friends and brothers I've been going there so long. The delicious homemade crumb cake that tastes like Sunday morning. The Vongole that I ate tonight that is definitely in the top three and SoFlo. If your a pretentious snob, the atmosphere is a pizzeria BUT it's a 5⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ pizzeria 🌹❤️😎

    Corrie ritornato
    -
    April 25, 2026

    First time trying after reading lots of positive reviews. Our Pizzas and garlic knots were outstanding. Loaded with toppings. In restaurant at counter many other choices we will try next time. Chris introduced himself and pointed out and described each item on display. Will be a regular pizza spot for sure!

    Diane L
    -
    May 28, 2026

    Fantastic pizza! Made the way it should be. Right amount of sauce and cheese. Crust delicious 😋 Wings good also! One problem and I know it's not the pizza parlor it's uber. They neglected to give me my coke. The driver must go home at night with a bunch of items.

    Johnny Pies Pizzeria

    Our Address

    Next To Publix, 4855 Coconut Creek Pkwy, Coconut Creek, FL 33063, USA

    Advertise Your Restaurant in the Land O Lakes Local Business Directory!

     

    Read More

    Increase Your Restaurant’s Visibility and Exposure on the Internet!

    Read More

    Is YOUR Restaurant Listed in Our Directory?

    List YOUR Restaurant in Our Directory!

    Basic Listings are FREE!