Johnny Pies Pizzeria

Next To Publix, 4855 Coconut Creek Pkwy, Coconut Creek, FL 33063, USA

About Johnny Pies Pizzeria

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Sant Scott
    -
    October 16, 2026

    Johnny is the MAN! An authentic NY slice that can’t be beat (especially in a city that is lacking spots like these). Customer service is always great, and they provide such a welcoming atmosphere. Ingredients are top notch, and is the most consistent pizza spot in Fort Lauderdale! Can’t recommend them enough, I urge you to try them at least once (because after you try it… you’re going to be coming back for more!) Super affordable lunch menu as well. KEEP KILLING IT!

    Kk C
    -
    June 21, 2026

    I’m from Brooklyn, New York, and it’s been incredibly difficult to find a true NYC-style pizza down here. This place is, by far, the best New York-style pizza I’ve tasted since leaving home! The flavor, crust, and authenticity are exactly what I’ve been searching for. Not only is the pizza amazing, but it’s also a great place to sit down and enjoy a meal. The staff is awesome—super friendly, welcoming, and always makes you feel right at home. Bring your family, bring your friends, and come hungry because two slices are definitely not enough! They also have a large selection of other incredible specialty pizzas, so there’s something for everyone. If you’re looking for authentic New York-style pizza and a fantastic dining experience, I highly recommend this place. You won’t be disappointed!

    Chris Anders
    -
    June 19, 2026

    Great staff super friendly and you can tell they love making this delicious food… This my favorite Pizza/ Italian eatery in Broward… The sauce is just a perfect blend and balance… The pizza forget about it absolutely bomb! But my favorite thing on the menu is the Sicilian rice balls 10/10… give the a try you like it!!

    Dean Capps
    -
    August 16, 2026

    A lot of places claim to have “Authentic New York Pizza” but usually fail to hit that mark. I’ve eaten hundreds of New York pizza and this is the closest you will find in south Florida. I ended up getting a large pep and it definitely didn’t disappoint. Definitely give this place a try.

    Cathy
    -
    August 08, 2026

    Great pizza! Had ordered a few pies for my classmates and had a pizza party which went better than expected. Everyone loved the pizza, even our optometrist got a slice! The delivery driver was very nice and got everything we asked for. Even included plates and utensils! Will order from here again!

    Johnny Pies Pizzeria

    Our Address

    Next To Publix, 4855 Coconut Creek Pkwy, Coconut Creek, FL 33063, USA

    Advertise Your Restaurant in the Land O Lakes Local Business Directory!

     

    Read More

    Increase Your Restaurant’s Visibility and Exposure on the Internet!

    Read More

    Is YOUR Restaurant Listed in Our Directory?

    List YOUR Restaurant in Our Directory!

    Basic Listings are FREE!